Cost of Metal Roof vs Shingle Roof (2025 Comparison)

Roof shingles on top of the house, dark asphalt

Cost of Metal Roof vs Shingle Roof (2025 Comparison)

Roof shingles on top of the house, dark asphalt

Understanding the cost of metal roof vs shingle options in 2025 is essential for homeowners looking to replace or upgrade their roof. Both roofing materials offer unique benefits, aesthetic appeal, and performance; yet, they differ greatly in terms of price, longevity, and maintenance requirements. Whether you’re trying to stay within a tight budget or looking to make a long-term investment, knowing the real differences between these two options can help you make a confident decision.

In this blog, you’ll learn:

  • How much metal and shingle roofs cost in 2025
  • What factors influence pricing and overall value
  • Which roofing material is better suited for your long-term goals

Let’s dive into the key comparisons that matter most to homeowners like you.

💵 Initial Installation Costs in 2025

When comparing the cost of a metal roof vs shingle roof, the price difference is significant at first glance. However, it’s important to consider what you’re getting for your money.

Metal Roof Installation Costs

  • Average Cost per Square Foot: $9 – $16
  • Total for 2,000 sq. ft. roof: $18,000 – $32,000
  • Materials: Steel, aluminum, zinc, or copper
  • Labor Costs: Higher due to complexity of installation

Metal roofs cost more upfront, largely due to material quality and the specialized labor required for proper installation. However, this cost often balances out over time through lower maintenance and longer lifespan.

Shingle Roof Installation Costs

  • Average Cost per Square Foot: $3 – $6
  • Total for 2,000 sq. ft. roof: $6,000 – $12,000
  • Materials: Primarily asphalt shingles
  • Labor Costs: Lower due to ease of installation

Asphalt shingles remain the most budget-friendly roofing material in 2025. Their widespread availability and quick install time keep labor and material costs down.

⏰ Lifespan and Long-Term Value

While initial pricing plays a big role in decision-making, considering the lifespan and total cost of ownership is just as important.

Metal standing seam roofing system on house

Lifespan of Metal Roofs

  • Average Lifespan: 40–70 years
  • Warranties: Up to 50 years or more
  • Best For: Long-term homeowners and those who want low-maintenance solutions

Lifespan of Shingle Roofs

  • Average Lifespan: 15–30 years
  • Warranties: Typically 20–25 years
  • Best For: Budget-conscious homeowners and short-term stays

When comparing cost over decades, metal roofing often provides better long-term value—even if it requires a larger investment at the start.

🔑 5 Key Factors That Influence Roof Cost

To get a more complete picture of metal and shingle roofing costs, consider these important variables:

1. Roof Size and Complexity

  • Larger roofs cost more due to additional materials and labor.
  • Roofs with multiple valleys, dormers, or steep pitches are more difficult and expensive to install.

2. Material Choice

  • Metal types like copper or zinc are premium options, raising costs dramatically.
  • Architectural shingles cost more than 3-tab asphalt but offer better performance and curb appeal.

3. Underlayment and Extras

  • High-performance underlayments are often required for metal roofing.
  • Ice and water shields, ventilation systems, and flashing all affect the final price.

4. Labor Rates

  • Labor costs vary by region and contractor experience.
  • Metal roof installers require more skill, often resulting in higher hourly rates.

5. Tear-Off vs Overlay

  • Removing an old roof adds labor and disposal fees.
  • Shingles can sometimes be installed over existing layers; metal typically requires a full tear-off.

🛠️ Maintenance and Repair Costs

Both types of roofing come with different maintenance expectations, which should be factored into long-term cost planning.

metal sheet roofing on new construction with blue sky

Metal Roof Maintenance

  • Minimal maintenance: occasional inspections and cleaning
  • Less prone to mold, moss, and leaks
  • Repairs are rare but more expensive when needed

Shingle Roof Maintenance

  • Requires more frequent inspections
  • Higher risk of granule loss, curling, and water infiltration
  • Repairs are cheaper but may be needed more often

Metal roofs usually win in terms of durability, meaning fewer headaches and repair bills over the years.

💡 Energy Efficiency and Insurance Savings

Choosing the right roof isn’t just about installation and maintenance—it can also affect your utility bills and insurance premiums.

Energy Efficiency

  • Metal Roofs: Reflect more sunlight, reduce heat absorption, and lower cooling costs
  • Shingle Roofs: Absorb more heat, especially dark-colored ones, leading to higher cooling needs

Insurance Incentives

  • Some insurance companies offer discounts for Class 4 impact-resistant roofing, which includes many metal options
  • Shingle roofs typically don’t qualify for the same level of insurance savings

Although metal roofs cost more upfront, they may help you save money on energy and insurance over time.

🏠 Curb Appeal and Resale Value

Beyond the functional benefits, roof aesthetics can also affect your home’s resale value.

Metal Roof Appearance

  • Available in various styles: standing seam, corrugated, metal tiles
  • Comes in multiple colors and finishes
  • Modern and sleek aesthetic with high-end appeal

Shingle Roof Appearance

  • Traditional look that matches most homes
  • Comes in different colors and textures
  • May not add as much perceived value for resale

In today’s market, a metal roof can enhance curb appeal and help attract buyers willing to pay more for long-term durability and energy savings.

Close up of new asphalt shingles installed on roof

🌲 Environmental Impact

Roofing material can also play a role in your home’s sustainability.

Metal Roofing

  • Often made from recycled materials
  • Fully recyclable at end of life
  • Longer lifespan reduces landfill waste

Shingle Roofing

  • Petroleum-based, with limited recycling options
  • Shorter life span means more frequent replacements
  • May contribute more to landfill waste over time

Eco-conscious homeowners often favor metal for its sustainability and long-term environmental benefits.

📋 Summary: Cost of Metal Roof vs Shingle Roof

Here’s a side-by-side comparison of both roofing types based on key metrics:

FeatureMetal RoofShingle Roof
Upfront CostHigh ($9–$16/sq. ft.)Low ($3–$6/sq. ft.)
Lifespan40–70 years15–30 years
MaintenanceLowModerate to high
Energy EfficiencyHighModerate
Resale ValueHigherModerate
Environmental ImpactLowerHigher

⭐️ Choose the Right Roof With J-Tech Construction & Solar

When comparing the cost of metal roof vs shingle roof in 2025, it comes down to your goals, budget, and how long you plan to stay in your home. Shingle roofing may be ideal for those seeking affordability, while metal roofing is perfect for homeowners who value long-term durability, energy savings, and low maintenance.

At J-Tech Construction & Solar, we believe in helping homeowners make smart, lasting decisions. Our expert team will walk you through the pros and cons of each roofing material, provide a transparent estimate, and ensure your roof is installed with top-tier craftsmanship.

Ready to explore your roofing options? Contact J-Tech Construction & Solar today for a free estimate. Your perfect roof starts here.

Categories

Ready to Get Started?

Are you ready to talk with a J-Tech Construction representative about your exterior and solar needs? Complete the form and one of our highly trained experts will reach out to schedule your free consultation. We look forward to working with you!

Name*
Address*
How Can We Help You?*
JTech Construction, Gutters, Lincoln, NE